SecurityCertified

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Monday, May 24, 2010

More on Black Hat Costs

Posted on 6:48 PM by Unknown
About a year ago I wrote Black Hat Budgeting, explaining how an offensive security team might spend $1 million. I said

"I submit that for $1 million per year an adversary could fund a Western-salaried black hat team that could penetrate and persist in roughly any target it chose to attack."

Tonight Jeremiah Grossman asked via Twitter:

jeremiahg@taosecurity regarding black hat budgeting, does defense-in-depth exacerbate the value cost inequity for defenders http://is.gd/cnGW9

I was tempted to squeeze some sort of reply into less than 140 characters, but decided to answer here instead.


  • First, vulnerability research is not free. Funny enough the No More Free Bugs movement is about one year old now. Charlie, Dino, and Alex are right -- it costs real resources to find vulnerabilities in software, with the level depending on the target.

  • Second, exploit development is not free. It is not trivial to devise a reliable, multi-target, stealthy-if-necessary exploit for a discovered vulnerability. Projects like Metasploit have made it a little easier since the days of one-off code for every proof of concept. Still, professional exploit writers still spend a lot of time on Metasploit, commercial alternatives, or their own mechanisms.

  • Third, victim management is not free. Everyone likes to talk about "risk management." Let's flip that notion around and think from the intruder's perspective. One of the features separating amateurs from professionals is the degree to which the intruder can manage his or her presence in the victim enterprise. The greater the persistence of the intruder the more professional the intruder, almost by definition. It takes a decent amount of work to stay present and/or undetected in an enterprise, depending on the defender's capabilities.


So, black hats have a lot of costs to manage, beyond those in my original post. I can pretty confidently argue, however, that intruder costs are dwarfed by defender costs. To the extent that "defense in depth" (DiD) applies additional costs yet do not meaningfully reduce exposure and vulnerability, DiD does indeed "exacerbate the value cost inequity for defenders."

Aside: a quick way to identify ineffective DiD is to review network diagrams showing "firewall stacks." I mean, seriously, in 2010, who needs more than one "traditional" firewall on a network segment? 10 or more years ago I remember network security people thinking you needed multiple different firewalls to they would each "catch something different" or cover for errors. These days everyone lets 80 and 443 traverse the firewall so malicious traffic just uses those services. How much money is wasted on these "traditional" designs?
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Happy 7th Birthday TaoSecurity Blog
    Today, 8 January 2010, is the 7th birthday of TaoSecurity Blog . I wrote my first post on 8 January 2003 while working as an incident resp...
  • More on Chinese Stealth Fighter and APT
    Since my 27 December post Courtesy of APT , featuring the new Chinese stealth fighter, Aviation Week writer Bill Sweetman wrote more about t...
  • Report on Instances of US Forces Abroad
    Thanks to Steven Aftergood's post Instances of US Forces Abroad I learned of a new Congressional Research Service report of the same na...
  • Security Conference Recommendations
    After my post Bejtlich Teaching at USENIX Security in San Francisco 8-9 Aug a reader asked the following: Richard, I was curious if you cou...
  • I Want to Detect and Respond to Intruders But I Don't Know Where to Start!
    "I want to detect and respond to intruders but I don't know where to start!" This is a common question. Maybe you have a new...
  • Security Onion + (ELSA or Snorby) + CapMe = Awesome
    Happy New Year everyone, and with some new open source software, what a year it will be. Monday Doug Burks released Security Onion 12.04 . P...
  • Manga Guide to Statistics vs Statistics in a Nutshell
    I took statistics classes twice in undergrad (once during the normal school year, a second time during a summer program at another school), ...
  • Review of Digital Triage Forensics Posted
    Amazon.com just published my two star review of Digital Triage Forensics: Processing the Digital Crime Scene by Stephen Pearson and Richard...
  • Does This Sound Familiar?
    Now that over a week has passed since this Economist article was published, I wanted to cite it and ask if the problem it describes sounds ...
  • Bejtlich Teaching at Black Hat West Coast Trainings
    I'm pleased to announce that I will be teaching at  Black Hat West Coast Trainings  9-10 December 2013 in Seattle, Washington. This is a...

Categories

  • afcert
  • Air Force
  • analysis
  • announcement
  • apt
  • attribution
  • bestbook
  • blackhat
  • books
  • breakers
  • bro
  • bruins
  • certification
  • china
  • cisco
  • cissp
  • cloud
  • clowns
  • commodore
  • conferences
  • controls
  • correlation
  • counterintelligence
  • cybercommand
  • cyberwar
  • dfm
  • education
  • engineering
  • feds
  • fisma
  • freebsd
  • GE
  • ge-cirt
  • hakin9
  • history
  • impressions
  • information warfare
  • ipv6
  • law
  • leadership
  • malware
  • mandiant
  • microsoft
  • mssp
  • nsm
  • offense
  • oisf
  • packetstash
  • philosophy
  • pirates
  • powerpoint
  • press
  • psirt
  • reading
  • redteam
  • reviews
  • russia
  • sans
  • sec
  • sguil
  • snorby
  • spying
  • threat model
  • threats
  • Traffic Talk
  • training
  • tufte
  • tv
  • ubuntu
  • usenix
  • verizon
  • vulnerabilities
  • wisdom
  • writing

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (16)
    • ►  September (1)
    • ►  August (1)
    • ►  June (2)
    • ►  April (2)
    • ►  March (1)
    • ►  February (3)
    • ►  January (6)
  • ►  2012 (60)
    • ►  December (4)
    • ►  November (5)
    • ►  October (3)
    • ►  September (10)
    • ►  August (2)
    • ►  July (6)
    • ►  June (6)
    • ►  May (4)
    • ►  April (2)
    • ►  March (9)
    • ►  February (6)
    • ►  January (3)
  • ►  2011 (108)
    • ►  December (3)
    • ►  November (7)
    • ►  October (11)
    • ►  September (9)
    • ►  August (18)
    • ►  July (10)
    • ►  June (5)
    • ►  May (4)
    • ►  April (13)
    • ►  March (17)
    • ►  February (2)
    • ►  January (9)
  • ▼  2010 (193)
    • ►  December (14)
    • ►  November (11)
    • ►  October (6)
    • ►  September (16)
    • ►  August (15)
    • ►  July (26)
    • ►  June (15)
    • ▼  May (15)
      • National Security Strategy is Empty on "Cyberspace"
      • Digital Security Is Not Just an Engineering Problem
      • "Privacy" vs "Security" or Privacy AND Security
      • More Evidence Military Will Eventually Defend Civi...
      • SANS WhatWorks Summit in Forensics and Incident Re...
      • Forget Pre-Incident Cost, How Much Did Your Last I...
      • More on Black Hat Costs
      • Watch Your WHOIS Entries
      • Review of Masters of Deception Posted
      • Review of Cyberpunk Posted
      • Review of The Hacker Crackdown Posted
      • Everything I Need to Know About Leadership I Learn...
      • Papers Not PowerPoint, Plus Tips for Improvement
      • Bejtlich to Speak at SANS Forensics and Incident R...
      • The Face of Information Warfare
    • ►  April (15)
    • ►  March (16)
    • ►  February (19)
    • ►  January (25)
  • ►  2009 (123)
    • ►  December (10)
    • ►  November (17)
    • ►  October (21)
    • ►  September (13)
    • ►  August (20)
    • ►  July (21)
    • ►  June (21)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile